If it doesn’t add, it subtracts

The hidden cost of fundraising reminder emails

That second reminder email feels harmless. So does the third. One more nudge before the deadline can’t hurt, right? 

It can. Lee Wochner has a rule for this, one he developed over years in the theater: If it doesn’t add, it subtracts. In theater, a scene where nothing changes is a scene that should be cut. Fundraising campaign messages work the same way. A message that moves nothing forward is noise, and donors are very, very good at tuning out noise. 

In this episode of How to Market Your Nonprofit, Lee, CEO and Creative Strategist at Counterintuity, draws on his other life as a playwright and stage director to show how to build a campaign where every message earns its place. 

Why reminders fail 

A typical Giving Tuesday campaign runs like this: a save-the-date in early November, then “Giving Tuesday is next week,” then “Giving Tuesday is tomorrow,” then three emails on the day. Every one is about the calendar. None is about a person. Nothing changes from one message to the next except the deadline getting closer. Lee’s test: If you deleted your second reminder email, would anyone feel the story was missing a piece? 

Give donors news instead of reminders 

Lee walks through three elements of plot that give a campaign somewhere to go: 

  • The inciting incident: Something changed, and it answers the question every donor is silently asking: Why now? 
  • What’s at risk, revealed over the campaign instead of all at once: Start with one person, widen to everyone facing the same thing, then show donors how their gift can tip the outcome. 
  • An honest, specific obstacle, with the donor as the one who overcomes it. 

Progress against an obstacle gives you something to say that isn’t a reminder. As Lee puts it, “We cleared half the waitlist overnight” is a scene. “Don’t forget to give” is not. 

A Giving Tuesday campaign in five scenes 

Lee maps out an example campaign, from the opening story a week out to the morning, midday, and evening updates on Giving Tuesday itself. It uses the same number of touches as a typical reminder campaign, maybe even fewer, but every one carries news. 

Don’t skip the ending 

The message most Giving Tuesday campaigns forget is the one that comes after. Tell donors what happened, close the loop on the story they started with, and make your thank-you a curtain call where the donor takes the bow. The resolution of this campaign is the first scene of your relationship with them for next year. 

Where to start 

Pull up the outline of your next campaign. Go through it message by message and ask the director’s question: What changes in this scene? If the answer is nothing, rewrite it or cut it. 

Lee would love to hear how your fundraising story turns out this year. Contact him here or find him on LinkedIn.


Jaclyn Uloth:
Welcome to How to Market Your Nonprofit, the Counterintuity podcast featuring interviews with experts in marketing, fundraising, strategy, and leadership who offer how-tos and inspiration about how you can help your nonprofit succeed and grow during a time of chaos and change. Bringing his 25 plus years of experience in marketing, strategy, and nonprofit management, here’s our host, Lee Wochner.

Lee Wochner:
Picture this. You’re sitting in a theatre, a playhouse. The audience is ready. The house lights dim down to black.  An actor walks to center stage, looks out at the audience, and says: “Reminder: The play is happening tonight.”

Twenty minutes later, a second actor walks out and says: “Just a friendly reminder, the play is still happening.”

Then a third: “Last chance! Only a few hours left in the play!”

Not the best play you’ve seen, right? Almost anyone would walk out.  And yet that is exactly how most nonprofit campaigns are built. Giving Tuesday, year-end, the gala. A series of reminders, each one a little more urgent than the last, and none of them telling a story. If that’s not the play you’re doing, great. I commend you. But honestly? That’s the play I feel like I’m seeing most of the time when it comes to fundraising:  we’re here raising money, we’re here raising money, hey, we’re still here raising money.

And I understand why.

But today I want to walk you through how to build a campaign that’s more engaging. A campaign that has a plot.

Well, how do I know how to do that, right? Sure, I’m the CEO and Creative Strategist at Counterintuity, where we’ve spent nearly two decades doing marketing, strategy, and creative work  for nonprofits and mission-driven organizations.

But for even longer than that, I’ve had another life, and it’s relevant today. I’m a playwright and a stage director. In fact, I wrote — AND directed — my first play in high school when I was 15. I’ve had plays produced in New York, Los Angeles, around the United States, and in London. For 10 years, I was the founding artistic director of a theatre dedicated to developing and producing new plays by emerging writers. And for 36 years I’ve taught writing and storytelling,  at universities, at writing conferences, and in private workshops.

Here’s what all those years in rehearsal rooms and classrooms have taught me. The tools that make a play work are the same tools that make a campaign work. A play has a point, one idea that every scene serves. In technical terms, we call that a theme, and so we look for something called thematic unity. If it isn’t united to the theme, it’s irrelevant — it’s in the way of the objective, which is to get an audience reaction. A play runs on desire, characters who want something badly. And a play has a structure, and most times that structure goes like this: something happens, the stakes rise, obstacles get in the way, and we build to a moment of decision.

So in the next fifteen, twenty minutes, we’ll cover four things. Why reminder campaigns fall flat. How desire and a clear point set up your campaign. The three engines of plot: the inciting incident, the stakes, and the obstacles. And then we’ll walk through a Giving Tuesday campaign, scene by scene, so you can see it in action.

Let’s be honest about what a typical Giving Tuesday campaign looks like. For most of them, there’s a “save the date” email in early November. Then “Giving Tuesday is next week.” Then “Giving Tuesday is tomorrow.” Then three emails on the day: morning, afternoon, and “only hours left.” Maybe a social post with a progress thermometer.

Every one of those messages is about the calendar. None of them is about a person. Nothing changes from one message to the next except the deadline getting closer.

In theater, we have a word for a scene where nothing changes. We call it a scene that should be cut. Every scene in a well-made play has to move something: a relationship shifts, a secret comes out, a choice gets harder. If a scene could be removed and the audience wouldn’t notice, it doesn’t belong.

Here’s THE rule of thumb that I’ve developed in the theatre — and it applies to everything in life. Trust me on this. This is a big takeaway. Here goes: 

If it doesn’t add, it subtracts.

That’s it. If it doesn’t add, it subtracts.

When you have four characters on stage, but three of them are involved in an argument and the other is just there mixing drinks, he subtracts.

When there’s something in the middle of the road, it isn’t adding to your driving experience, it’s subtracting.

When you’ve got things in your life that aren’t adding to your life — like clutter! — every study on the subject shows that they subtract from your well being.

Apply that test to your campaign. If you deleted your second reminder email, would anyone feel the story was missing a piece? If the answer is no, that email isn’t a scene. It’s noise. And your donors are very, very good at tuning out noise.

Before we talk about structure, two things have to be in place. Every playwright learns these first, and they’re the two things I see missing most often in nonprofit campaigns.

The first is desire. When I direct actors, the most important question I ask isn’t “What are you feeling?” It’s “What do you want?” What do you want in this scene? What does your character want? That’s why when I was teaching playwriting at a major university, I taught Stanislavski method.  The great acting teach Konstantin Stanislavski called it the superobjective: the deep want that drives a character through the whole play. Desire is what makes an audience lean forward. We watch to find out whether the character gets what he or she wants.

In your campaign, there are two characters with wants. There’s the person you serve: the child who wants to be adopted, the family that wants a safe place to sleep. And there’s your donor, who wants something too. Maybe to feel useful. To be part of something that works. To honor someone they loved. Your campaign’s job is to bring those two desires together on the same stage.

The second thing is the point. The theme. The one idea that  the whole production is about. Even absurdist plays seemingly without a plot — such as “Waiting for Godot” or the works of Eugene Ionesco — have a theme. When a play has thematic unity, every scene, every design choice, every line serves that idea. When it doesn’t, the audience leaves confused, even if individual moments were good. Because things didn’t add up.

Most campaigns try to be about everything: all six programs, the new building, the anniversary, the matching gift. Pick one. Write it in a single sentence. Something like: “This Giving Tuesday is about making sure no kid in our county starts school hungry.” Every message you write from here on has to serve that sentence. If it doesn’t, cut it. Because it’s subtracting.

Every play begins in a kind of balance. Then something happens that knocks the world off its axis. The ghost appears to Hamlet. A stranger knocks on the door. That’s the inciting incident, and without it, there’s no story. There’s just a description of how things are.

Here’s where some nonprofits could do better. They open their campaign with the description. “We serve 4,000 families a year.” “Our mission is to…” That’s the world in balance. Nothing has happened yet.

Your campaign needs an event. Something that changed, something that’s new, something that makes this moment different from every other moment. It might be a rise in demand: “This fall, our waitlist doubled.” It might be a loss: a funding source ended. It might be an opportunity: a matching donor stepped forward. Or it might be a single person’s story: “On September 12th, Maria walked into our office with her two kids and nowhere to go that night.”

The inciting incident snaps people into attention. The inciting incident also answers the question every donor is silently asking: why now? If you can’t answer that, your donor can always give later. And later usually means never.

Stakes are the answer to a simple question: what happens if the character doesn’t get what they want? In a good play, the answer gets worse as the story goes on. The stakes rise.

Notice I said rise. A lot of campaigns announce the stakes once, at full volume, in the first email, and then just repeat them. That’s like a play where the climax happens in the first scene. There’s nowhere left to go.

Instead, reveal the stakes in layers. Start personal: what happens to Maria and her kids tonight. Then widen the frame: Maria isn’t alone; there are forty families on the same waitlist. Then bring it back to the donor: the matching gift expires at midnight, and if we don’t reach it, those dollars go unclaimed.

One caution, because I’ve seen this go wrong. Stakes are not the same as guilt. You’re not trying to make your donors feel bad. You’re trying to make them feel that their choice matters, that the outcome is genuinely open, and that they’re the one who can tip it. That’s what an audience feels in the best moments of a play. Not guilt. Investment. Leaning in.

Desire plus obstacle equals drama. That’s the oldest formula in storytelling, first documented by Aristotle in his Poetics. If a character wants something and simply gets it, there’s no play. The story lives in the gap between what someone wants and what’s standing in the way.

Nonprofits are often reluctant to talk about obstacles. We want to look competent. We want donors to believe everything is under control. But a campaign where everything is under control gives the donor no reason to step in.

So name the obstacle, honestly and specifically. “The shelter has 30 beds and 70 people asking for one.” “The grant that covered our winter program ended in June.” “We’re $12,000 short of the match with six hours to go.”

And here’s the turn that makes it work: the DONOR is how the obstacle gets overcome. In a play, the protagonist faces the obstacle. In your campaign, the donor gets to be the protagonist. The hero. Your organization is the guide who shows them the path. When you name the obstacle and then hand the donor the means to beat it, you’ve written them into the story.

Obstacles also give you something most campaigns lack: news. Progress against an obstacle is a reason to send a message that isn’t just a reminder. “We cleared half the waitlist overnight” is a scene. “Don’t forget to give” is not.

Let’s put it all together. Imagine a family shelter planning its Giving Tuesday campaign. Their point, their theme, their one sentence, is: “No family in our city should spend a winter night without a safe place to sleep.” Here’s the campaign as five scenes.

Scene one: the inciting incident. About a week out, one email and one social post. No ask yet. Just Maria’s story. September 12th, two kids, nowhere to go. We end on the question the audience needs answered: what happened to them?

Scene two: the stakes rise. A few days later. Maria got a bed. But she was one of the lucky ones, because the waitlist has doubled since summer. Now we widen the frame. Forty families. Winter coming. This is where the donor learns what’s really at risk.

Scene three: the obstacle. The day before Giving Tuesday. We name it plainly: the grant that funded winter beds ended in June. And then we introduce the turn. A board member has offered to match every gift on Giving Tuesday, up to $25,000. The obstacle now has a solution, and the donor holds the key.

Scene four: the rising action. Giving Tuesday itself, and this is where most campaigns send three identical reminders. Instead, each message reports what changed. Morning: “We’re live, and the match is on.” Midday: “You’ve already funded twelve beds. Here’s a note from our night manager.” Evening: “$6,000 left to unlock the full match.” Every message is a scene because every message carries news. There’s a reason that telethons used to adopt this form, and that public radio and public television have done it for so long:  because it works.

Scene five: the resolution. The day after. This is the scene almost everyone forgets, and I’ll talk about it more in a second.

Notice what we did. Same number of touches as a typical reminder campaign. Maybe even fewer. But each one moves the story forward, and each one gives the reader a reason to open the next.

Imagine sitting through two hours of a play, and right at the climax, the lights cut out and everyone is sent home. You’d never know how it ended. You’d feel cheated. That’s how a lot of donors feel on the Wednesday after Giving Tuesday. They gave, and then silence. Or worse, the next email is already asking for year-end.

Every story needs a resolution. Tell your audience what happened. “Because of you, we unlocked the full match. That’s 60 winter beds, starting December 1st.” Close the loop on the character they met in scene one: “Maria and her kids moved into permanent housing last week.” Let them feel the ending they helped write.

And then, the curtain call. In theater, the curtain call is when the audience gets to applaud and the actors get to say thank you. It’s a moment of shared celebration. Your thank-you message is your curtain call. Make it specific, make it warm, and make the donor the one taking the bow.

Here’s the practical payoff. A donor who saw the ending is far more likely to buy a ticket to your next show. The resolution of this campaign is the first scene of your relationship with them for next year.

So let’s recap. Before you write a single email, know the desire: what the people you serve want, and what your donor wants. Know the point: one sentence that every message serves.

Then build your plot. Open with an inciting incident that answers “why now.” Raise the stakes in layers instead of shouting them all at once. Name a real obstacle, and make the donor the one who overcomes it. Make every touchpoint a scene that carries news. And never skip the ending and the curtain call.

Here’s a challenge for this week. Pull up the outline of your next campaign, whether that’s Giving Tuesday, year-end, or your spring event. Go through it message by message and ask the director’s question: what changes in this scene? If the answer is nothing, rewrite it or cut it.

Now it’s time to get ready to share your story with the world. And hey — please let us know how YOUR fundraising story winds up this year. We’d love to hear the result. Email me at lee AT Counterintuity dot com or find me on LinkedIn.

Thanks for listening. Really appreciate you for being here today.

Jaclyn Uloth: Thanks for listening. How to Market Your Nonprofit is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and wherever you get your podcasts. Please like and follow the show. Visit counterintuity.com to learn more.

Scroll to Top