The hidden cost of fundraising reminder emails
That second reminder email feels harmless. So does the third. One more nudge before the deadline can’t hurt, right?
It can. Lee Wochner has a rule for this, one he developed over years in the theater: If it doesn’t add, it subtracts. In theater, a scene where nothing changes is a scene that should be cut. Fundraising campaign messages work the same way. A message that moves nothing forward is noise, and donors are very, very good at tuning out noise.
In this episode of How to Market Your Nonprofit, Lee, CEO and Creative Strategist at Counterintuity, draws on his other life as a playwright and stage director to show how to build a campaign where every message earns its place.
Why reminders fail
A typical Giving Tuesday campaign runs like this: a save-the-date in early November, then “Giving Tuesday is next week,” then “Giving Tuesday is tomorrow,” then three emails on the day. Every one is about the calendar. None is about a person. Nothing changes from one message to the next except the deadline getting closer. Lee’s test: If you deleted your second reminder email, would anyone feel the story was missing a piece?
Give donors news instead of reminders
Lee walks through three elements of plot that give a campaign somewhere to go:
- The inciting incident: Something changed, and it answers the question every donor is silently asking: Why now?
- What’s at risk, revealed over the campaign instead of all at once: Start with one person, widen to everyone facing the same thing, then show donors how their gift can tip the outcome.
- An honest, specific obstacle, with the donor as the one who overcomes it.
Progress against an obstacle gives you something to say that isn’t a reminder. As Lee puts it, “We cleared half the waitlist overnight” is a scene. “Don’t forget to give” is not.
A Giving Tuesday campaign in five scenes
Lee maps out an example campaign, from the opening story a week out to the morning, midday, and evening updates on Giving Tuesday itself. It uses the same number of touches as a typical reminder campaign, maybe even fewer, but every one carries news.
Don’t skip the ending
The message most Giving Tuesday campaigns forget is the one that comes after. Tell donors what happened, close the loop on the story they started with, and make your thank-you a curtain call where the donor takes the bow. The resolution of this campaign is the first scene of your relationship with them for next year.
Where to start
Pull up the outline of your next campaign. Go through it message by message and ask the director’s question: What changes in this scene? If the answer is nothing, rewrite it or cut it.
Lee would love to hear how your fundraising story turns out this year. Contact him here or find him on LinkedIn.

